This Shabbos is parshas Vayetzei. This link on Aish HaTorah's website discusses the dynamic between Rachel and Leah (which I won't try to paraphase or discuss here!). Now this is a story I've been familiar with since I was a little girl. And I remember being able to relate to Leah. The poor girl was 'overlooked' and left for her fairer sister Rachel. Ok, ok, so now I know that Leah was not exactly a straight-shooter; turns out she had a few character traits inherited from Laban it seems.
Genes, lines, families. I wonder, if Leah had this "blemish" on her character, why did Hashem find it suiting to give Leah most of Jacob's children? True the 'redemptive' line is brought down through Rachel, but why should the tainted outweigh the bad? This is of course conclusions based on the idea that intangible traits like attitude, intelligence and character are influenced by your forefathers (and foremothers).
Since I'm a woman, I'm going to be biased and look at the women in my own family. Hmmm...ok, so my Mother and I are like night and day. Physically, we look alike; personality-wise, we may as well be from two different planets. Moving up the line - to the Grandmothers; my Father's mother had a lot more courage than I have. She was also willing to put her own wishes aside to cater to every need of her children. I don't know if I can compare her and I because I don't have children and her's were so central to her existence. My Mother's mother is like a living doll; too delicate to be real. She is the type of woman who does things such as tapping you one the shoulder and saying "Hey, I love you!" and praying over you before you do - well anything. Things that you to embarrass me immensely when I was younger. She gives me a great example to shoot for; but we don't have much in common either. Going up even further (staying on my Mother's side because that is all I know); both Great-grandmothers were very strong, religious women with forceful conviction in their faith. Active no only in their respective churches but also known nationally as achiever's in the C.O.G.I.C. (Church of G-d in __ ) movement. I am descended from such women?
This Shabbos, hundreds of thousands of Jews will sing אשת חיל to the woman of the household. A Jewish woman who is the cornerstone to the continuation of the Jewish people. But in each stanza of that zemirah, I can see at least one of my own, non-Jewish matriarchs. What a surprise - Shlomo HaMelech sees what I see (or perhaps it should be the other way around)! As a potential convert, many people ask me how I can "change" so much? Don't I feel "strange" doing all of these things. Truth be told - I feel more as if I am coming full circle than anything else. Tznius? My Grandmother who raised me never wore slacks a day in her life - she sees the value in modest dress, that's for sure. Kashrus? My Father's mother had to deal with raising two vegetarian sons in the 70's - back in the days when there was no Whole Foods Market in every shopping center. Hair covering? Black women with their hats in church is a subject that books have been written about.
Of course the differences are great; but the life of a Torah-observant woman feels much less strange to me than the life of a woman in a mini-skirt and heels in the clubs on the beach.
Jewish women, no matter how they secular world may try to corner them off and say, "Look, she's so oppressed! She's not seen as equal in the eyes of the Torah!" are not phased or detracted from what they are. They know their essence is their neshamot. I remember that as a young child, I did not daydream about "girlie" stuff like getting married or having children. I was not opposed to the idea either (I understood that women should feel pride in playing "the mommy role"), but it was not central to my future. I wanted to "do stuff" and "be somebody". The older I became, the more pressing this idea was on my mind. But was I not already "somebody". I was at that point (17, 18 years old) what Hashem wanted me to be. But in my eyes it meant nothing. Perhaps deep down it did; but society was saying, "Hey, you need a title; you need some accomplishments; you need a trip to the salon and a personal trainer!". Just so that you can be - what? So I can complete myself? So tell me, when will I be complete?
Last night I took a walk from my office to Pita Loca; which takes me through about 8 blocks of South Beach; the essence of trendy materialism in it's highest style. I saw a young woman who was trying on a dress in a boutique. Although she wasn't looking for the attention - just trying to model in front of the mirrors to see if she wanted to spend the oodles of money on the outfit, a couple tourists started playing amateur photo shoot and she had a bit of a crowd. I cannot say that I know what it feels like, but if I was in that position I would feel dehumanized. Here are people who don't even know my name - who haven't even heard my voice - yet they want to get close to me and take my picture. Then they will take that picture and do what with it? What will they say about me upon showing it to whoever? It probably won't be bad, but it will surely be about my appearance. The essence of me - my soul - will be constantly overlooked and glossed over.
I found myself thinking about if I ever had a daughter what would I say so that she is never in such a position? Through dejection, disappointment, and heartache I learned that those attracted to you on superficial aspects such as appearance have a very tough time getting an accurate idea of the person you are. On the other hand, personal pride in healthy doses does manifest itself in good hygiene, keeping your body in shape, and having a stylish appearance - much like the models on this site.
I mentioned that my own Mother and I are very different; however I don't think that words can give proper justice to the comparison between us. Sure, we look a lot alike - to the extent that some people have mixed us up with each other. However the personality of the woman who gave birth to me was not passed on. She did not live with me; she had little if any effect on my daily environment as a child.
I have 4 younger sisters; one who's name is Rachel as well. She on the other hand looks nothing like her mother; to the point where some people (even she) have voiced surprise over my sister's appearance. Because Rachel is very young, it's hard to see which parent her "spirit" follows; maybe neither.
I made a huge detour trying to get to the question - Is the Jewish soul passed through heredity or environment? I mentioned how in אשת חיל I find familiarity. But in relation to the environment I was raised in, and not necessarily the woman who is my immediate predecessor. Could this be the hidden secret of the importance of the Jewish woman? The tribal affiliation (i.e. - "name") is passed on through the father but the Jewish home itself, the בית הקדש is maintained by the women.
A convert in Judaism 'loses' the familial ties to their natural cases simply because they become a Jew, while the family remains non-Jews - which prohibits them from specific Jewish ritual and services. But my family has helped cultivate me. Hashem created the seed, and put into impetus the growth but they are the ones who watered me, threw in some fertilizer, and pruned me every now and then.
Perhaps it does not matter so much the characteristics of the Jewish matriarchs - or patriarchs for that matter. Jews do not have "magic genes" that make them better people than gentiles. But they do know the secret; or more specifically, Jewish women know the secret, of how to transfer "character" to the next generation. What an awesome responsibility; what a priviledge to be endowed with such a task!
The Most Famous Ramban in Chumash – The End of Parshas Bo
-
The Ramban at the end of Bo is a classic work on Jewish philosophy and
probably the most quoted Ramban in Chumash. It’s well worth seeing inside.
Here’s ...
3 months ago


4 comments:
Wow, Miss Shona, thank you for sharing. That was deeply personal, but universal at the same time. I think people have potential based on our genetic limitations, but we are shaped by our life experiences. No matter how much we talk about our ideals, it is the role models in our lives that we eventually learn to follow. Sometimes this can endow us with negative traits, even from small events that we would have thought insignificant. But most importantly, it does mean that we have an ability to set our lives in any path we choose, even if we rely on Gd to carry us to the destination.
Great post, very interesting read.
I liked the way you compared Halachah and things that follow it because of circumstances (like vegetarianism and hats).It reminds me of the guy who said I never ate chalav akum, why? because I'm lactose intolerant.
Jewishness is a funny thing. It is temporal but it is also spiritual. My experience and observation tells me that Jewishness is an issue of one's socialization. This is why Jewish education is so important. Without Jewish education and socialization there is no Judaism and no Jews.
You and I were not raised Jewish but we assimilate ourselves into a Jewish lifestyle. We carry out basically normal lives within our respective Jewish communities. Meanwhile there are people born of two Jewish parents who live like complete and total gentiles with almost no knowledge or observance of anything Jewish (I have had the awkward experience of being on dates with such people). Give these people a generation or two and Jewishness will be an issue of their "background" and something they are not actively living with.
At the same time, as I explained to a non-Jewish businessman I was having lunch with today, you can do as many Jewish things as you like, but if your mother was not Jewish and you have not had a Halachic conversion, you are not Jewish. period.
It has been said that Jewishness is passed matrilenially exactly because it is the woman that does most of the socializing of the children in the home. Historically, men have gone out to "bring home the bacon", so to speak.
Also, regarding the similarities you see between Judaism and aspects of other religions and cultures, I have come to the conslusion that Judaism does not have a lock on many concepts. For instance, I had a coworker who followed a Holistic lifestyle. In many ways it was EXTREMELY similar to Orthodox Judaism. She wore long skirts and covered her hair and looked like a married Orthodox woman. She had strict dietary restrictions that made kashrut keepers look like slackers (kashrut keepers can at least eat meat, etc.). And if you ask the reasons why they do it, the answers will be 80% the same as the answers you would get from a Rabbi. Generally speaking, these concepts started with Judaism and spread to others. But the fact remains that a lot of other people are doing things that started within Judaism first.
So why do I do the things I do? Because I am bonded to the Jewish people - we all are. And as such we express our bond by doing the mitzvot that we do.
You never really lose your family of origin. There may be added distance, but unless they disown you or you disown them, they are still your family and know you in a way that others can't. I have seen a similar thing with Ba'alei Tshvuah. Their basic personalities never change. Their lifestyle does. I never realized how steeped I was in Black American culture until I up and moved to Israel. And other Black Americans are the only prople who really understand me on that level. Now there is a gulf when it comes to Jewish issues, but the way I see it, I am just as Black as I was 10 - 15 years ago. I am just as much "the different one" in my family now after converting as I was 10 - 15 years ago. I am just a little more different than before.
But maybe that's just me. Another Black woman I knew who was converting and converting Orthodox in Israel (or at least wanted to, but then converted Conservative in the US so she could marry her fiance sooner) was from a family of serious Bible enthusiasts who admired Judaism and Jewish tradition and didn't have to deal with the casual anti-Semitism that I have to deal with in my family. You know what Ahmedinejad just said about Israel being moved to Europe? One of my aunts said that a few years ago. As you can imagine, I did everything I could to stay far away from home and limit my visits.
Anyway, I have gone on too long. Keep writing!
Very true what you said about other faiths emulating Judaism. Islam does this especially.
Post a Comment