Ok, I'm a little late on this because I have been extremely busy my first week back to FL. I want to give publicize the fact that Pittsburgh's Jewish community in Squirrel Hill; specifically the Shaare Torah Congregation, was a stellar community in which to spend Pesach. It was an experience that was very valuable to my neshama.
Nevertheless, I will probably decline to ever go away for yontif (at least as a single woman in an "open" {a kosher cruise/resort/hotel may be ok} environment) again. You see, for Chol Homoed, I stayed with my family. It was stressful, I had to do a lot of explaining, and for lack of a better way of putting it, I lost my "groove" for the chag. Much of the confusion stems from the fact that while my desire to become Jewish is not a new thing for my family, previously, it did not interfere to much with my home life. You go to church, I go to synagogue. I celebrate Hanukkah while you do X-mas (I would just wrap my gifts in the blue & white Hanukkah paper and give them earlier/later). But now it's a whole new ball game. Last time I went to Pennsylvania was about 17 months ago. A lot has transpired in that time.
May I list "pros" and "cons" that I felt or perceived?
Pros:
1) My Grandparents liked the tznius clothes. Especially my Grandmother, who said "I was taking pride in my appearance (I guess she thought I wasn't do so before???)."
2) I declined my Grandfather's fried delicaces; staving off about 5-10 lbs of weight gain in the process.
3) My demeaner is calmer and my language has improved. Ah, and to think of my college days when my Grandmother would say, "What did you just say?" and I would repeat the phrase sans the mild curse word I had said previously.
4) I hold a lot more respect for my Grandmother's relgiousness and my Grandfather's wisdom/kindness than I did previously.
5) My sisters. They are the only family members who didn't question or raise eyebrows and anything I was doing or any explainations that I made about Judaism. Psstt...Adults, take a hint!. A high-five goes to both of them, ages 10 and 17.
Cons:
1) The food issue. Very, very difficult. I had always been a picky eater, but after 25 years, my Grandmother knows my favorites. But I insisted she didn't make them. She did anyway. And it's hurtful for both her and I in the end.
2) "You're going to Pittsburgh again?" I tried to soften the blow by saying I was staying with friends for the Passover services - that it would just be easier. But they sure didn't like the fact that I didn't answer my cellphone, or swing back over to my hometown when services were over.
3) Expense. No matter how I looked at it, there was going to be a lot of money wasted. Of the 11 days I had the rental car, 5 of them I wasn't able to drive. IF my family had a bigger handle on the situation, then maybe someone could have dropped off/picked up/dropped off to save $$$ for me. But it's hard enough explaining yontif to Jews; much less non-Jews who have also never been around Orthodox Jews ever.
4) Family life-cycle events. During my stay, there was a funeral for a cousin. While I realized I could not go to the church service, I decided to go to the burial. Too bad most people decided to do the reverse and my Mother told me (although she also admitted the church service was long and boring and her thighs hurt from sitting on the pews for so long!). I got some looks; but as also started squirming when they recited "The L-rd's Prayer" (although the words in that prayer are not heretical - it still brought back "the old days"). I wondered if I would ever again be able to attend the life-cycle events in my family again comfortably?
5) Old friends. I ran into a few. They sort of scratched their heads at my long sleeves and skirts. I mean I had moved to Florida, bikini-land, and this is all I owned?
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
After the trip I was exhausted and felt a bit forlorn. I couldn't wait to get back to Miami where I could go back to my kosher Thai & sushi, my shirium, and my own house where I know the cooked food is ok to eat. On the other hand, I do miss my family; but I see so much more clearly now that we function in two different realms.
It was during this trip that I realized that Hakadosh Baruch Hu makes everything happen in it's own time. 2 years ago, I would not be ready to "let go"; 1 year ago, I would not have the fortitude to stick to my guns about kashrus. Most of all, I wouldn't have been able to come home as a Jew. To have left there with only revereance to G-d, but with no observance, and to pop in on the scene as "The Cannot Do Girl" would have been too much.
But my story does not have a sitcom ending. My family does not totally understand and only mildly support my endeavors. At least now I have a better idea of what I have to work with; and they can see that my becoming a Jew is not totally "all bad".
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
There was another sore spot which I did not mention and warrants it's own post really. That is their general disapproval of my trip to Israel. To my family, Israel is a land of terrorism, deserts and daranged bloodthirsty Arabs. The exeption is my father, my auntie, and my G-dmother.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Totally unrelated, I haven't had the chance to read any seforim by the Chofetz Chaim, but I really want to work on lashon hara. Really. I want to desist from casually offering criticism of any member or portion of Klal Yisrael. I can be cynical, so this undertaking will be a constant 'work-in-progress'.
The Most Famous Ramban in Chumash – The End of Parshas Bo
-
The Ramban at the end of Bo is a classic work on Jewish philosophy and
probably the most quoted Ramban in Chumash. It’s well worth seeing inside.
Here’s ...
3 months ago


4 comments:
This post brings back memories. After 6+ years keeping kosher and 5+ years keeping shabbat visits at home are getting easier. My family has somewhat adjusted to all the things I can't do on shabbat and can't eat. Soon my mother's remodeling will be done and that will help with the "light in the bathroom issue" since we'll have a seperate bathroom on a different floor from the rest of the family.
Good luck finding that balance.
What your family thinks about Israel is ironically quite true in spirit although doesn't exactly reflect reality of course :). What I mean is that it just isn't very nice country and living alongside arabs isn't nice either, in many aspects. I have been living here for five years already, so I speak from experience, and although it seems that some ppl like it there, most don't. You'll probably see by yourself if you ever visit, and more and more so as time passes. So generally I'll wait with proclaiming that you want to make Jerusalem your home until spending at least a year there.
Um, with all due respect 'anonymous', I appreciate your comment, but I feel it is purely an opinion - nothing more, nothing less. People and places are not as simplistic as we would like to believe. This is a very big world, with a lot of different people and ideas. I'm sure that if money, transportation, political restrictions, and family were no issue, 80% of the planet's residents would all move to the U.S.A. Why? Because of the way the US culture has creeped into everyone's existence as being superior. And yes, even as much as Europeans profess to hate us, that includes them too.
For those of us who live here, it can be or cannot be, what we dream life to be like. Why? Priorities of course.
You may want to define what is it that makes Israel "bad"? Walking outside fearing for your life? Shortage of jobs? No place to find a good deal on a new Land Rover? Do you realize those problems are prevelant in many places, including the US?
I'm not quite sure where you picked up on the notion that I 'want to make Yerushalayim my home' except for in my profile there. But that is something all relgious Jews pray for. Rather it's a theoretical statement or not is hard to say. But I will say that I would prefer to live in Yerushalayim over anywhere else - if factors like money, transportation, political restrictions, and family were no issue. Why? Because the gains of residing and performing mitzvot in the Holy Land far outweigh any gain to be had elsewhere; including personal safety.
Let me dip one more level and get personal. Look at me. A young woman who cannot trace her family back more than 2 or 3 generations (thanks to this country - that regarded Black people as chattel); a college grad strapped with $50,000+ worth of debt just because I choose to "better myself" (yes, I will readily admit my family had no nest egg saved up to send me to college so me, myself and I had to do it); a decent citizen - whose values are thrown out the window because the prevalant attitude is that the beautiful and rich live by a different set of rules than the rest of us. I respect and honor how G-d made me, but the society I live in does not. To be intelligent, polite, and keep a modest appearance makes you nothing but a sucker in this "men with the big guns win" society.
I do not know what the future holds. I am not naive to the point where I think there is a Utopia somewhere. But I want to live my life in a way where I feel fulfilled and can give back to something more than the Social Security Administration. That can happen right here in the United States; but it can also happen elsewhere. The Torah named Israel for the Jews for a reason. I may not live to call Eretz Israel "my home" but perhaps my decendants (if G-d wills) will. I accept that fully; and while the grass is not always greener on the other side, if you get a hint from Hashem, it pays to heed it.
:)
Hello there,I stumbled over your blog again and remembered I've posted a comment. I didn't think you'll answer anyway I read your blog some more, and I have some more to say :)
You see, what you're writing about yourself and your plans is very similar to what I throught and even how I spoke before I made aliyah to Israel. I was also into teshuva and also in some crisis in my life. I imagined Israel is different from the rest of the world and I was really sure that coming to Israel will give my life a purpose...well I could've signed under everything you write.
In true however, I was just running away. As the initial shock passed I came to realize bit after bit that Israel is just the same as any other place. It really has no unique spiritual or whatever (personally I don't like the world "spiritual") qualities. It's just a place, a country populated by people like any other people. Some are good, some are bad, some are disgusting. People without parental support struggle even harder to pull through college since there are no real student loans here. And you are really doing them a disservice by assuming they are somehow different from the rest of the world because they are Jews. There is no special athmosphere and people in Israel don't relate to each other any different from people in other counries. Everybody just goes about his business and tries his best to make a better living. For many it means immigrating to US. As you rightfully noticed, given the opportunity most would go there, but not because of them being culturally brainwashed - they just want better, more secure living for themselves and their families. Some aspects of life are sure different from Europe, but the cause of differences is mostly economic one - Israel is relatively poor mediateranian country.
Anyway,I don't think you'll understand without really visiting. I think you should try living here for a while. Birthright won't show you anything - it's just a week long trip, and they mostly show you beatiful places - and Israel really has many. However, look out of the bus window, or look around you as you pass along the street - you'll see people just like in your hometown, nothing special about most of them, many living quite terrible lives. Some maybe will seem to you exotic, and that will quite surely be the most poor and ignorant ones. There really is no enchanting secret about their lives.
When and if you move to here on a permanent basis, try to make friends with native Israelis. It will help you to understand your surroundings better, and you'll see they have same problems as people in US do. I actually was lucky to find wonderful friends (just as I could in any other country), so nevermind all the problems, I don't regret my decision to immigrate, althrough I don't see my future here, and neither does most of them :)
Anyway, I wish you good luck whatever you decide :)
Post a Comment